
I had actually eaten off of Mi Tierra's menu before, during a catered lunch at CUAV several years ago. It was good but not particularly memorable. Today, however, I went straight for the pupusas.
I am on a quest to find the perfect Bay Area pupusa. Mi Tierra is the sixth restaurant I've tried, but the first I've reviewed. Previous venues include El Patio, Balompie, Platanos (SF and Berkeley varieties), and Panchita's. [I'll try to revisit these locales and write up reviews in the coming months.] The verdict: there's lots to like, but the overall experience is not as good as Balompie or El Patio.
Mi Tierra is spacious and brightly colored. Spanish telenovelas play on a large-screen TV in the back. I ordered (as is my wont) two loroco pupusas and a Diet Coke. The total bill was $5.60.
First, the good: The pupusas themselves were large and tasty. Mi Tierra uses more loroco than many other places, which gives them extra flavor. And they were not greasy or overcooked.
The problem lay in the accompaniments. I was intrigued by the curtido because it was made with jalapenos and hot chilis. Unfortunately, despite this, the slaw lacks flavor. It also lacked crunch, and some of the cabbage bits looked decidedly old. Likewise, the salsa was thin and runny.
In sum, the pupusas themselves compare favorably with the pupusas at El Patio and Balompie. However, the overall combination of pupusa, curtido, and salsa falls a bit short in terms of flavor and freshness. I'd rank Mi Tierra third in my pupusa rankings:
SF Pupusa Rankings
1. Balompie
2. El Patio
3. Mi Tierra
4. Platanos (Berkeley)
5. Panchita's
6. Platanos (SF)